跪拜 Guibai
← Back to the summary

The Group-Buying War Ends: Only Meituan Survived

Chapter 14: Only Meituan Remains | Chronicles of Internet Product Wars

※ This memoir is fictional literary creation. Real names of people in the text are only cited as background of the era; dialogue and details are artistically processed. Please do not take it personally; any resemblance is purely coincidental.

Chapter Summary: During 2011–2012, the Groupon-style group-buying war concluded. Meituan survived because of its combination of "internal discipline + the Longyan clique + Alibaba's old guard." Out of a thousand group-buying companies, only one or two remained. Lin Tao left group buying, his rank fell back to the seventh level, but he distilled the methodology of "refined management + relationship networks." At the end of the chapter, he accepts Old Zhou's invitation to return to Tmall, facing Singles' Day.


At the beginning of 2012, the thousand-group-buying war had settled.

As I expected: only Meituan remains.

Wang Xing and his Longyan people turned a money-burning carnival into an endurance race. In public reports, others raised funds to burn on advertising; he raised funds to refine systems. Others subsidized to grab users; he built merchant tools to retain businesses. Others expanded blindly into cities; he calculated city by city. When the wind stopped, pigs fell dead everywhere. Meituan, this "eagle," landed steadily on the branch. I was not jealous—a person who can endure, calculate, and root himself into merchant systems deserves to survive. The opponent had vision, which made this battle meaningful. I even admired him a bit: also a fierce character from Fujian (the Longyan clique later produced another one in the short-video era, but that's a later story). Wang Xing's group used "stinginess" to the extreme—that wasn't pettiness, it was reverence for the model.

Later, when I talked about Wang Xing, I always said: the scariest thing about this man is not his intelligence, it's his "slowness." Others burned money, he was unmoved; others expanded, he held back; others shouted about scale, he calculated. In public reports, Meituan spent a lot of energy in those years on delivery fulfillment and merchant systems. It looked slow, but it rooted itself into every small shop on the streets. Word has it that a report hung in his office—what he watched every day was "how many cents each order loses," not "how many cities did we open today." This kind of "dull effort" was the rarest thing in the thousand-group-buying war: most people died from wanting to be too fast. It was exactly what Xiao Gao's "subsidy blitzkrieg" lacked: one calculated for the long term, the other for the present.

When I left group buying, a "casualty list" circulated in the circle: of over a thousand group-buying companies, 90% collapsed. Xiao Gao's company was merged into another; he moved to a different direction (we reunited later in MCN, a later story). My group alliance was also acquired. My rank fell back to the seventh level. Not shameful—this was clarity bought with half a year of rank loss.

But I didn't lose that rank for nothing. The thousand-group-buying war gave me three things that served me for a lifetime:

First, the Three Commandments of the Wind. Don't burn money to buy users (bought users don't stay), don't board the wrong ship (when the ship sinks, people die), don't forget your relationship network (network here, people here). These three commandments were bought with my lost rank. Later, when I consulted for startups, my first sentence was these three commandments. Some laughed in the audience; after laughing, they followed them. The ones who survived were mostly the obedient ones.

Second, the refined-management instinct. Alimama taught me "tagging," and the group-buying war forced me to "bring tagging into street-level promotion." Later, whatever I did, I first broke it into layers, tagged it, and calculated—it became muscle memory. This instinct saved me in the Double 11 war room half a year later—that's a later story.

Third, reverence for the alumni/colleague network. Xiao Gao was on the other side, former colleagues lost jobs in droves—this network can support you, but it can also strangle you. From then on, every time I changed ships, I first checked "are there acquaintances in the network on the other side." This one saved me and also trapped me; it all depends on how you use it.

For example, "don't board the wrong ship"—when I jumped into group buying in 2011, the wind was strong and everyone thought it would succeed. But I forgot to ask: is this ship's bottom welded with financing? When the wind stopped, the ship leaked. In contrast, those who had solidified their supply chains kept going even when the wind stopped. This commandment cost me rank to buy; it was expensive, but worth it.

A few days before leaving, I went to the street-level promotion spot I used to lead. The boss lady of Pianchuan'ao Old Zhou Restaurant gave me a box of tea eggs, saying, "Manager Lin, if you leave, who will teach me to look at the member count?" I laughed and said the system is still there; you just follow the prompts. She didn't understand the system, only people—which was precisely the most precious thing in the group-buying war. I suddenly understood: what I lost in this rank drop was the obsession with "only trusting data," and what I got back was the clarity that "people also trust data." In this world, what makes people remember you for a lifetime is never how much money you burned, but the extra account you calculated for them.

That year, Aqiang, the kid on the street-promotion team, didn't follow me. He stayed at the merged company doing operations. At parting, he messaged: "Brother Lin, I remember what you taught me—'don't trust rebate coupons, trust data.'" A small person being able to take away one sentence made me more at ease than a payroll slip. The world is big; what remains is never money, but people.

In 2012, Old Zhou called from Alibaba: "Lin Tao, come back. Tmall's Double 11 needs people. This time it's real battle." I hesitated for a moment. That call from Old Zhou was the third bailout from the alumni association. The first was around 1996, when the thin teacher from Hangzhou Dianzi University was not yet famous, but someone in the alumni circle was already saying "Ma Yun is going to start something called Alibaba"; the second was in 2008, when Old Zhou personally came to recruit me back to Hangzhou; the third was this 2012 call. Among the three networks, the alumni association was like a quiet life preserver—invisible normally, surfacing only when you sink. Twenty years ago, Ding Lei's one sentence "come to Guangzhou with me" made me quit the factory; ten years ago, Old Zhou's "come to Alibaba" brought me back to Hangzhou; now another phone call was pulling me back from the ruins of the group-buying war to the main battlefield.

"OK," I said. After hanging up, I remembered the screech of the modem in 1996. The wind was coming again—this time it was Double 11, the cat-and-dog war, the new traffic era after 2012. I had to get into the water. The moment I said "OK," I didn't hesitate long. The muddy water of the group-buying war was long overdue to leave; and this thread of Alibaba's alumni association had been tied to my waist since the 1996 screech—loose at times, but never broken. Ding Lei pulled me to Guangzhou, that was the hometown association; Old Zhou called me back to Hangzhou, that was the alumni association—the Zhejiang clique and Hangzhou Dianzi University, two ropes, dragged me from one end to the other, never letting me truly drift away in thirty years.

That night after hanging up, I tossed and turned, unable to sleep. Half a year in the group-buying war taught me one thing: every time I "got into the water," there was sure to be an acquaintance in the network on the other side. Returning to Tmall, the opposite side was JD—on JD's side, would there be people I know? This thought stuck like a thorn under the excitement. The colleague network never lets people come ashore easily.

Before leaving, I messaged Xiao Gao: "Next time we meet, let's not be on opposite sides." He replied: "That depends on which ship you're on." I laughed. In this world, there are no fixed seats on ships. But I had a faint premonition: on this trip back to Tmall, on the opposite ship, there would likely be another person I know standing—the colleague network never lets people be at ease; it always gently pushes you back into the water just when you think you've reached shore.

In the spring of 2012, I walked through Alibaba's gates again. The campus in Xixi was several times bigger than when I left four years ago, glass curtain walls reflecting the Jiangnan rain. This time, it wasn't B2B, it was Tmall; not a talent war, but the Double 11 war room. When I swiped my employee card at the front desk, the machine beeped "di" as if saying: you're back again. The front-desk girl glanced at me curiously, probably thinking I was an old bird returning to the nest. Walking through the glass corridor, I ran into an old acquaintance—the junior from the Sohu days, now doing merchant recruitment at Tmall. She smiled in surprise: "Brother Lin, you're back here too?" Her words made me laugh: this colleague network, looping around, gathered scattered old colleagues under the same roof. I suddenly felt a bit choked—I thought I had left group buying, but actually I had never left this network. And I knew that on the opposite ship stood an even more unexpected acquaintance—this world, after going around in circles, pushed old friends back to my sight.